Since this is my domain of terror... I'll take a crack at it.
Full Moon Wo Saga****e
Awesome shoujo romance anime... but you need to get through the first 15 episodes which are extremely slow. This anime has a love square and is a major tear jerker.
This anime is based on a shoujo smut manga but Smut Queen Shinjou Mayu. The manga is concentrated solely on the romance between the lead singer and his lyrcist but the anime is more about how the band makes it big. If you can get through the first 20 romance-less episodes the last 20 are pretty full of standard shoujo stuff.
This is just standard. You have to watch it.
I always refer to this anime as every magical girl shoujo romance cliche rolled into one package. It's awesome. Another must see.
Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Live Action)
This review is for the live action but the anime is freaking awesome as well.
:O The romance takes a back seat but this is a very angsty shoujo drama about baseball.
Another magical girl anime with romance elements. This is cute. I recommend it to anyone who likes sailor moon.
Also Magical Girl but this whole series centers around love. I loooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooved it. Especially the end. ._. *dies*
Animes that we don't have reviews for... yet:
Hana Yori Dango: http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/ency...me.php?id=1136
Seriously one of the best shoujo romances ever. If you haven't seen it yet go now!
I liked the manga better but the anime was very true to the manga. Standard but, really juicy love triangle... square... hmm.
.... best.... shoujo... anime... ever.
Magical Girl anime with a lot of romance. By the same creator of Marmalade Boy.
...second... best... shoujo... anime... ever.
*shameless plug for CoTRJ*
For anyone interested in this kind of anime we have a club for it: